Don’t Leave Your Trading Team Guessing: The Five I's of a Good Trade Request

What does a box of Ikea furniture without instructions and a trade request missing half of its details have in common?
They both cause headaches & will probably be done incorrectly.
Your trading team can do a lot, but even the best team can’t read minds. When it comes to trading, unclear instructions can lead to unnecessary back-and-forths, delayed requests, and higher risk of trade errors. With just a little preparation however, these hiccups can be completely preventable.
A good trade starts with a good trade request. Below is what your trading team needs to know before a trade can be placed. As a bonus, we’ve also included a trade request checklist that you and your team can implement.
The Five I’s of a Good Trade Request
Identification
Your trading team opens their computer and sees a trade instruction that reads, “Place trades for Ms. Johnson.”
As an advisor or CSA, you may know who Ms. Johnson is and which of her accounts has an upcoming deposit. Your trading team doesn’t necessarily have the same face-to-face interaction with clients like you do however; They don’t know who Ms. Johnson is and when they search “Johnson” on your custodian platform, they’ll probably see several different Johnson portfolios that belong to different Johnson households, leaving them confused and messaging you for context.
To avoid confusion, provide your trading team with the following identification:
Client name & account number (or your firm’s approved identification method)
If a client has multiple accounts, specify exactly which account is involved.
For new accounts, confirm that the account is open, funded, and available for trading.
Instruction
The previous trade instruction has been updated and now reads, “Place trades for Ms. Nancy Johnson in her Roth account ending in 0000”.
Your trading team now knows what account needs to be traded, but now they’re left confused as to what trades to place, how much to buy or spend, and if there is any other relevant trade information they need to be aware of. This is a recipe for trade errors.
To minimize the risk of trade errors, provide your trading team with further instruction:
The security symbol.
Whether to buy or sell.
The dollar amount, share quantity, or percentage to trade.
Any relevant order instructions or restrictions.
Whether the request is a one-time trade or part of a broader portfolio change.
Intention
The most updated version of the previous trade request now reads, “One-time request: Buy 100 shares of AAPL in Ms. Nancy Johnson’s Roth IRA ending in 0000.” Your trading team has a lot more to work with now, but they may be wondering what the intention behind this trade is.
Your trading team spends their days inside portfolios, and with more information they may notice missing details or potential conflicts that may have been overlooked by the person who initiated the request. Knowing the intention behind the trade request allows your traders to serve you best with their deep knowledge of what is going on within the portfolios.
Importance
Your trading team now knows what account to trade, what to do, and why they’re doing it. Now they may want to know when the request needs to be handled by. Your trading team juggles a lot of tasks and trade requests, and they need to prioritize their time appropriately.
Let your trading team know how high of a priority the request is and when they should have it completed by. This sets up reasonable expectations for everyone and allows your trading team to prioritize their time efficiently.
Information
Not every trade requires the same information. If there is any extra information that is necessary or good to know, be sure to share it with your trading team.
Here are some examples of additional information that your trading team should know:
Contributions & Deposits: Share the contribution amount, confirmation that funds have arrived and are available to trade, intended investment instructions or allocation, and any relevant model or account-specific restrictions
Distributions & Cash Raises: Share the amount to be raised, requested date and client payment deadline, whether cash is readily available, any relevant tax, security, or account-level considerations.
Rebalancing & Model Changes: The approved target allocation & model; whether the change applies to one account, selected accounts, or an entire group; any exclusions, restrictions, or account specific deviations; and the intended scope and timing of implementation.
Account Transitions: Account identifiers and transition status; assets expected to arrive or already received; holdings to retain, sell, or review; and relevant cost basis information, restrictions, and transition instructions.
Before You Hit Send: A Quick Trade Request Checklist
Before you send your trade request to your trading team, walk through the checklist below to ensure that your trading team has all of the information they need.
Correct client & account are identified
Buy/sell instructions are explicit
Security or securities to be traded are clearly identified
Dollar amount or quantity instructions are included
The trade objective is clear where needed
Relevant deadlines and priorities are noted
Available funds, incoming assets, or other dependencies have been addressed
Restrictions, exclusions, and special instructions are documented
Required approvals and supporting documents are in place
Want to spend less time managing trades and more time managing your clients? Fill out our interest form below to tell us about your firm, your current trading process, and where you could use additional support. From there, we’ll work together to determine if Sage Trading Collective is the right fit for your team.





Comments