How About Them Apples? 🍎 A Fresh Take on Tax-Loss Harvesting
Updated: Oct 29

How about them apples? While you and your family are harvesting those apples, squashes, and pumpkins, we are making sure that our clients are harvesting their losses.
Many people think that losses in an investment account are always a bad thing. But here's the thing, having a lot of gains in an account can result in a big tax consequence. And we know your clients don't want to pay more money to Uncle Sam than they need to.
For those of you who are not familiar with tax-loss harvesting, it is selling investments at a loss to offset realized capital gains and potentially reduce a client's tax liability.
One of the advantages of working with Sage Trading Collective is that we work with many firms. From smaller RIAs who just left the big shops to bigger RIAs who have a good foot in the game. We get to see how different firms do things, and through those experiences, we've learned a lot along the way. Based on what we've learned from other firms and our own experiences, here's a tax-loss harvesting workflow that we've found works well.
1. Look for Tax-Loss Harvesting Opportunities
Identify which lots have unrealized losses, their holding periods, and their cost basis. Use specific-lot identification when appropriate.
If you're using a trading tool like Schwab iRebal, here is a simple process that you can use:
Set the Rebalance Type to Tax Loss Harvest and name the rebalance.
Choose Position Level:
Select Position level if you only wish to harvest when an entire holding in an account can be sold while meeting your thresholds.
Select Lot level if you are willing to sell partial holdings as part of tax loss harvesting.
Add the symbol(s) of the securities you wish to sell, as well as the equivalent replacement securities, or leave blank if leaving in cash.
Note: Make sure to use appropriate replacement securities. Maintain market exposure by purchasing a similar, but not substantially identical, investment. Confirm replacements comply with approved security sets.
Input the "Sell if loss is greater than" settings using a dollar or percentage threshold. Many of the advisors we work with are unsure what threshold to use. If you’re in the same boat, feel free to reach out to Sage Trading Collective for assistance!
Submit and see what the harvesting opportunities are. Place the trades in the accounts in which you would like to harvest those losses!
2. You've Harvested Those Apples (Losses). Now It's Time to Set Up Those Guardrails to Prevent Wash Sales
A wash sale generally occurs when an investment is sold at a loss and the investor purchases the same or a substantially identical security within 30 days before or after the sale.
Here's something important to remember: The wash-sale window actually covers 61 days. That's 30 days before the sale, the day of the sale, and 30 days after.
So, before harvesting those losses, make sure you're checking for recent purchases, including automatic investments, dividend reinvestments, and purchases in other applicable accounts. Just because you haven't bought the security back after the sale doesn't mean you're in the clear!
Fun fact: According to IRS Publication 550, wash-sale rules can apply across spouses' investment accounts. However, the IRS does not identify sharing a mailing address alone as a condition that triggers a wash sale. Therefore, accounts should be reviewed based on ownership and applicable tax relationships rather than mailing address alone.
Source: IRS Publication 550, Wash Sales
At Sage Trading Collective, we love "elbow pads and knee pads" on in the trading platforms that we use. Because let's be honest, we are all human, and mistakes can happen, especially when you're trading in mass.
Just like riding a bike, just because you've never fallen in the past doesn't mean you won't fall in the future. Same with trading. Just because you haven't missed things before doesn't mean you won't miss things in the future.
So, what protective gear do we use at Sage?
Security Restrictions: If you recently sold a holding at a loss, we suggest adding a Never Buy, do not trade restriction or something similar for that ticker to help prevent accidental repurchases during the wash-sale window.
Portfolio Tags: Tags are great for being able to filter out accounts and not even include them in the equation. Consider adding a “TLH” tag. This another exclamation point to help you think, "Oh hey, I better be careful when trading this account."
Portfolio Notes: This is something newer that we've been doing, thanks to one of our newest clients who shared this great idea with us. A Never Buy restriction is good, but if that's the only thing, the trader still may be confused.
Here is a good example of a note you would see in our TLH accounts:
"TLH - Using USFR for SHY 10/21 - 11/22 | DNB (do not buy) SHY"
Spreadsheet: The good ol'-fashioned spreadsheet. Many of us traders know that this is usually the keeper of the keys. If you don't use a trading platform, or if you would like another guardrail, we suggest keeping a client considerations spreadsheet that includes the account name, account number, and any special considerations, like TLH notes.
Note: Remember to add these guardrails to ALL accounts in the same household.
3. The Wash-Sale Period Is Over. Now What?
We know the wash-sale window is 30 days before and 30 days after the sale. But at Sage, we'd rather be safe than sorry, so we shoot for waiting at least 31 full days after the loss sale before repurchasing the security.
That extra day gives us a little breathing room, but remember, waiting 31 days after the sale doesn't eliminate a wash sale caused by purchases made before the sale. That's why checking the full window is so important!
Once the applicable wash-sale window has passed:
Remove the temporary security restrictions, portfolio tags, portfolio notes, and entries in the spreadsheet that are no longer needed.
Buy back into the model, if appropriate.
And just like that, you have some beautifully harvested apples… oops, we mean losses.
This is one of the only times we can tell a client, "Great news! We realized some losses in your account!" and they actually thank us.
Just don't wash away the good news with a wash sale! 😉
And if you've gotten to the end of this article and are thinking, "I don't have time for that on top of my marketing, financial planning, therapist work, operations work, and compliance work," we understand!
That's what we're here for. We want to make sure you have time to focus on what matters most, your clients.
We've put together a great checklist to use during tax-loss harvesting! There's a lot to remember, and we don't want anything to fall through the cracks.
Fill out our form, and we'll send you our tax-loss harvesting checklist!
Disclosure
The information shared in this article is intended for general educational purposes and reflects tips and practices we've found helpful when managing tax-loss harvesting. Every firm operates differently, and what works for one firm may not be the best approach for another.
We encourage you to do your own research, review your trading platform's capabilities, and determine which processes, restrictions, and procedures work best for your firm's needs, policies, and compliance requirements. Tax-loss harvesting strategies should also be evaluated based on each client's individual circumstances and applicable tax rules.
This article is not intended to provide individualized investment, tax, or legal advice.





Comments